Showing posts with label eggy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label eggy. Show all posts

Monday, November 10, 2014

An odyssey in pain and glory.

  
Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl is a 3DS remake of the DS RPG Etrian Odyssey.  One important change is the Story mode.  Story mode adds new areas to the original game, along with additional bosses.  To play Story mode is to be further challenged than simply playing the Classic mode.  In Story mode you can not even choose the class of your characters, meaning you're stuck improvising through Grimoire stones.  Together these factors form the hardest Etrian Odyssey experience yet.  This will matter in a bit.

Right now, I have 107 hours invested in Etrian Odyssey Untold for 3DS.  For me, that's a lot of time in a game.  To say I have a love/hate relationship with Untold would not even begin to describe the bittersweet hell it's put me through.  I mean, I thought I was an RPG god yeah, but after being forged in the fires of Untold's fury for over 100 hours... I realize just how weak I was before it.  Sure I've beaten such "tough" classics as Phantasy Star I & II, Vagrant Story, Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne, Valkyrie Profile, and others of their ilk.  But those games are child's play compared to Etrian Odyssey Untold.  I have become a far more potent RPG player due to Untold's challenges.

That is, Etrian Odyssey Untold on Expert.


Yes, I'm playing this game on Expert, and on Story mode to boot.  Now, you might be wondering why I'd play this game on its hardest combination possible.  After all, I could be playing it on Picnic or Standard difficulty.  That is precisely what most people do.  I could have beat this game in 25 hours on Picnic, or 45 hours on Standard.  So why Expert?  The answer to that question is not a simple one.  There are multiple reasons why I'm suffering Etrian Odyssey Untold on its evil Expert difficulty level.

The first reason is one of simple spite.  Last year I was involved with a debate on a forum I won't mention, concerning the concessionary difficulty changes of Etrian Odyssey Untold and Fire Emblem: Awakening.  Fire Emblem has a long history of being an uncompromising strategy series, with its core feature being that if one of your characters dies in battle, they are dead forever.  Etrian Odyssey's series' core feature is it is designed with oldschool hardcore difficulty in mind.  That means the Etrian games do not hold your hand, and will kill you in a heartbeat with no kid's gloves whatsoever.  These elements gave both Fire Emblem and Etrian Odyssey their core distinction; pure unadulterated challenge.  A series identity.  Easy mode is not an option.


All that changed with the 3DS though.  Fire Emblem: Awakening introduced the option to turn permanent death off.  And Untold introduced the option to change the difficulty to Picnic (press A to win) or Standard (pay attention and press A to win).  In order to play Untold on traditional Etrian Odyssey difficulty, you need to choose Expert.  You can even willy-nilly change the difficulty of Untold at any given time.  That means if you're fighting a boss that is destroying you, instead of having to overcome the challenge through tactical resilience, you simply turn down the challenge.  Likewise instead of playing Awakening more intelligently, just turn off perma-death and you can just resurrect your screw ups.  Challenge be damned, everybody's a winner here!  I for one am not okay with "no gamer left behind".


No gamer left behind.  I said exactly as such on said forum.  And there's where I got in trouble with some of the members.  Everyone started calling me the dreaded E word.  And I don't mean Experienced, or Elucidated, or Erudite even.  Nope, they called me an Elitist.  I was being "elitist" to say that hard games have a right to exist, and that they should not dilute themselves to sell better to the lowest common denominator.  I took great offense to this, because I am not an elitist folks.  I'm a Refinist.

Yes "refinist" is a word I made up.  There may be an existing word to describe this, but we need neologisms from time to time.  What's a refinist then?  Someone who refines themselves of doubt when faced with challenge.  Someone who tenaciously perseveres through strife until they have purified themselves of weakness, and ultimately accomplish the goal they set out to finish.  That's a refinist!  A refinist does not give up.  A refinist rather gets stronger, smarter, and tougher, and gets through adversity without artificial aid.  A refinist is insulted by a game that panders to their initial inability and offers training wheels to finish the race.  If we didn't have refinists?  The Tour de France would be ridden on mopeds.  The Olympics wouldn't exist.  We would not have made it to space.  But not everyone gets to be an astronaut!  It's true.  And not everyone gets to beat an Etrian Odyssey game.

That is, until Untold came out and made it possible for your dog to beat an Etrian Odyssey game.


So why does it piss me off, if I'm not an elitist?  Because I think people are capable of overcoming challenges if they really put their mind to it.  I believe in the inner strength of my fellow gamer.  I won't lie to you, many many times Untold has kicked my teeth in, ever taunting me to lower the difficulty.  I was stuck on one boss for almost a week alone!  But I never lowered it, and I will never lower it.  I will beat Untold on Expert, to prove a point, even if I'm only proving this point to myself.  Even if it takes 200 hours I will do this.  I will not cheat or glitch the game either.  I'll beat it, fair and square.  I will refine myself of weakness and become a strong enough player to pull this off.  There were people on said forum who said not everyone can do this, therefore Picnic mode has a right to exist.  Well I say those less determined people should stick with easy RPGs (dime a dozen) instead, and not encourage Atlus to dilute their original vision due to publisher pressure to sell more copies.


Developers.  Instead of rewarding players of little effort with "Congrats You Win", let's make them face up to true challenges instead.  Let them learn to value the taste of sweet victory after hard fought practice.  There's no Picnic difficulty switch on a guitar.  There's no Standard difficulty escalator on the side of Mount Everest.  We would laugh at such concessions in those instances, and mock their users deservedly so.  Yet it's okay to make traditionally hard video game series easier?  And you're an elitist if you disagree that it's not okay?  That's hypocritical nonsense.  Easy games have a place but so do hard ones.  Hard games build character.  I believe in gamers' character enough to know they can push through the challenges as long as they keep trying.  Spit on the training wheels and forget the floaties.  There's nothing quite like the glowing feeling of beating a truly hard game.  If you think that's not true, it's because you haven't done it yet.


NOTE: I did beat Etrian Odyssey Untold's Story mode on Expert, and it took me 115 hours.

Thursday, October 9, 2014

Are Video Games Art?


The painting shown above is known as Red on Maroon Mural Section 3.  It was painted by Mark Rothko in 1959 and it is the greatest painting ever painted.  Now that's in my opinion of course.  To call this particular painting the greatest ever is totally subjective.  I could understand then, why someone might think said painting isn't good at all.  But I would not understand anyone saying it's not even art.  A rational person is not going to point at an obvious artistic painting and say that it is not art, because by very definition that's simply what artistic paintings are.  And yet, we can also recognize when paintings are not obviously artistic...


The painting shown above is called NO PARKING.  And NO PARKING is probably not even meant to be artwork, despite being a painting.  As such, the average person seeing this wall painting would not recognize it as art, but rather as a warning suggesting not to park near it.  Culturally we can accept that paintings can be art, but can also not be art, depending on content and context. The same is true for the audio medium.  Albums can be art, but instructional audio books aren't meant to be.  Motion pictures can be artistic surely, but the medium can also be used for non-artistic means such as the daily news.  What about video games then?  As a medium do they follow the same logic?  Are some games meant to be commercial consumption pieces, while others are meant to be works of actual artistic expression?  Well let's take a minute to think about what goes into a video game first.


The first interesting aspect to consider is that video games contain all forms of common art.  Indeed, they are a melting pot of multiple mediums.  In the average modern game you've got your artwork, your music, your film, and your writing all bundled up into one experience.  That's a veritable gallery of artistic mediums intermingling in an electronic smorgasbord.  And beneath that still, you've even got a new form of art, programming.  (If you think programming is boring and there's no auteurism in the field, you may wish to reconsider.)  And of course there's the art of game design itself.  With so many avenues of artistic delivery in one container, how can one say video games aren't art?  Easily actually.  Let's go back to our melting pot symbolism to understand why.


The problem is that video games as a canvas are really just the melting pot itself, not the ingredients that provide the meal.  Take all the other forms of artistic media out of the video game (ingredients), and you're left with a cold empty pot (video game).  The contents within the pot were the individual pieces of artistic accomplishment.  Combined together, they didn't actually form a new type of art, just a collage of various forms of art.  It's a bit like putting a CD on top of a DVD on top of a book, and binding them together with duct tape.  Does that new pile of disparate mediums equal a new form of art, simply because they are bundled together?  Logically no.  Even if you could read the book, watch the DVD, and listen to the CD all at the same time purposefully, you're still merely experiencing disparate pieces of art simultaneously.  That's not experiencing a new form of art, rather it's simply experiencing multimedia.


Now the mix of multimedia can be convincing.  You might feel like you're really exploring a frozen wasteland in Skyrim.  But calling the artificial reality in a video game the "art" of what a video game is... well, that's the same as calling special effects in a movie the "art" of cinema.  The true artistry of a film is not in its special effects alone, those are just the icing on the movie cake.  Artificial reality in a video game is the same thing; it's just window dressing.  Convincing atmosphere is a means to an end, but not the artistic end in and of itself.  Yes gaming's artificial realities consist of various pieces of art coming together as a believable illusion, but said illusion is not a new art form.  It's a homogenous expression of multimedia.  Melted ingredients in a melting pot.  Lucky for us then that video games offer something very important that melting pots don't; interactive canvases for expression of free will.  And that is where the unique art form a video game offers truly resides.


This means two important things.  Number one, video games cannot become art without a player interactively experiencing them.  And number two, the player in doing so becomes the artist completing the work of art.  (Yes this is not a concept that can only be applied to video games, it's broader than that.)  Depending on how a player interacts with a video game, their experience will differ than that of another player.  This influential malleability of end perception means the player is the final artist completing the art experience started by its developers.  The player imposes their own free will upon the palette of possibility provided by the video game.   In return the video game modifies its expression as a result of this interactivity.  The player is the artist, the controller is the paint brush, and the video game is the canvas.  Is this art?  A new form of art?  I think so.  Now to use a simple analogy consisting of a paint by numbers picture...


A paint by numbers picture is a previously drawn piece of artwork meant to be painted over by the artist.  Normally the picture has suggestions as to which color correlates to which number.  But that does not mean you have to paint number 6 blue just because that's where the water is.  You could paint number 6 red, and that stream of water just became a brook of blood.  This changes the whole meaning of the painting!  Altering it from rote busy work to an actual work of art.  Thus this concept can be extrapolated to video games without much logical abstraction.  For example, you could play Super Mario Bros. in such a way that you never stomp on Koopa turtles.  Now you've just changed the way you interact with the game.  Now you're experiencing this new interaction as a game about how Mario is suddenly a turtle conservationist.  He's trying to rid their environment of other menaces such as Goombas.  See?  The way you play the game changes, and the game changes to you in return.


The true art of video games is not what they are made of, but rather what they offer when played; continuously changing expressionism altered by interactive use of free will.  Each player will walk away with a unique take on their experience differing from another player who's played the same game.  All based on how they alone played it.  That is the art of video games.  It has been said a movie, a book, or an album are artistic due to the ruminations and emotions one has upon experiencing them.  Video games have the exact same capability, doubly so because they can also make the player look inside themselves and question their own motivations.


After all, why did you squash that poor Goomba when you could have let him live?  Was he really trying to kill you, or just walking about his daily routine?  Reload the game, don't squash him this time, and the resulting rumination has changed.  In this manner, video games are the world's most dynamic form of art.  A living digital canvas that is being repainted by every new artist that interacts with it.  Indeed, video games are legitimately art, but only while they are being played.

Monday, September 15, 2014

The Bittersweet Backlog


I have a lot of video games.  Well, that's an understatement.  Honestly I probably own more video games than I could even finish before I die.  And yet knowing this, I still collect new games on a weekly basis.  More and more virtual voyages added to the unceasing pile.  With decades behind me of collecting, one could write it off as simply an old habit.  It might be that, but in a positive light one could say this is continuous library building for posterity.  Whether or not it's a good thing, the fact remains I own multitudes of video games I have not played yet.  They sit neatly organized and alphabetically congealed into segregated areas based on their respective platform.  Waiting patiently for their time to shine.  The truth is some of them will never get that chance.

It's not that I don't play, oh I play video games as much as I can.  "Can" being the operative word there based on playing in my free time.  My "free time" being that which I am not spending on my day job, adult responsibilities/chores, family obligations, relationship quality time, additional hobbies and other such necessities.  A mature responsible social adult cannot play video games with the same frequency they did as a carefree teen.  These days I average twelve to fourteen hours a week because of this reality.  I still have to sacrifice plenty of sleep just to pull off that amount.


Due to this situation I am a time traveling gamer.  As in, I play games from all eras of gaming.  This is born from having a backlog spanning decades.  There are still games I haven't played from the 8-bit era that I fully intend to play some day.  Despite their technological obsolescence.  All the same, I also play brand new modern releases.  But what I do not do, is disallow entire eras of gaming just because the next era has begun.  There are some people who do this.  "The PS4 came out?  The PS3 is now dead to me.  And don't even talk about the PS2 or PS1, that's just stone age crap."  To me this sort of thought process is needlessly dismissive, and illogical.  But from a purely technophile point of view, I guess I can understand their side of the argument.  I just don't share it.

An example of this?  Lately I've been playing King's Field (Japan), a game released in 1994.  It is 20 years old currently, but I've only just now gotten around to playing it.  One might wonder why I'd bother playing From Software's first release, when I've got a PS3 and their recent Dark Souls sitting in the same room (which I have not played yet).  I guess part of my reason would be due to scholarly inquisitiveness.  Historically speaking King's Field (Japan) is a significant release.  So to play an old game is to go back in time to a degree.  A larger degree though, is I'm able to disregard the graphical merit of a game, and rather enjoy its core gameplay as a separate entity.  This may have to do with growing up from Atari 2600 graphics.  I came from a time when gameplay sold a game as much (or more than) graphics did.   Having the ability to see beyond graphics is a double edged sword of course.  It means I can't disregard huge swaths of my backlog simply because of their archaic pixels.


Currently my backlog spans from the 1980's to 2014.  That's over thirty years of collecting.  So how does one begin to dig through a backlog that spans so many years?  Trying to prioritize what to play, and realizing one doesn't have time to play it all, can lead to backlog anxiety.  Feelings of shame, remorse, and loathing might manifest as a result.  I've been there!  I understand why folks come up with complex methods of dealing with this.  Some sort of regimen, or algorithm, designed to prioritize the top "must plays" or "most expensive rarities" of their respective backlog.  I am guilty of concocting such stratagem shenanigans myself in the past.   Let me tell you, that's a young man's game.  Age has brought me the realization that backlog anxiety is just silly and ultimately toxic.  The answer? Acceptance is the key.  It's not the same thing as apathy either.

Do I have too many video games?  Yes, and I accept that.  Do I need to stop buying them until I finish what I already have?  That would be financially logical, but psychologically unsatisfying, so no, I won't do that.  My fiance and I created a gaming budget for that instead.  Will I ever finish every video game I have?  Hell no.  I will be dead before that can even happen.  I accept that.  Is there a truly efficient way to choose what to play from one's backlog?  Maybe.  Do I really care?  Not anymore.  I accept that.  Instead I play what my ardent gamer heart yearns for, regardless of genre, release date, or game time length.  Hence I'm playing a Japanese oddity from 1994 right now.  Yes I could handle my backlog in a more efficient and hierarchical manner, I know this.  But I choose not to.  I accept that.


In reality my backlog is a monster.  It's a monster that I cannot slay, and yet I feed it more every week.  Maybe because I am in awe of its size and like to see it grow.  Or maybe my backlog is a well, keeping me hydrated in my unquenchable thirst for new gaming experiences.  And therein lies the two sides of the backlog coin.  Bitter monster, sweet well.  This is true, and I accept it.  But I no longer accept my backlog as a source of anxiety.  The librarian does not rue the library, nor the curator fear the exhibits.  Rather they revel in their potential.  And that is the beauty of a big backlog; pure potential.  That's why a pile of up-to-date-modern-only games can't match my backlog.  My crazy time spanning backlog is a monstrous well of potential.  And from it I can always sip a little joy as life permits.  So I throw a few coins in it every week, making the wish that it never runs dry.

Friday, September 5, 2014

Press A To Kill


Video games and violence.  Now there's two subjects you've probably never seen correlated.  I'm being facetious because yes, we've all seen this argument time and again.  I know I know, "Please not another article about how video games are unfairly victimized for violence in contrast to other mediums."  Relax, I'm not here to tell you the obvious.  Rather I will flat out say that yes, the vast majority of video games are violent.  You usually kill a lot of stuff in video games.  What I want to do with this post though, is talk about why we kill stuff in video games.  And why violence in video games is so prevalent.  And how all of that is actually... a good thing.  Now step into your local time machine, because it's time to go back to the past.


The very reason you are able to exist today, is because your ancestors were really violent.  Not necessarily for fun, rather for survival.  I'm talking about caveman and cavewoman times here.  The cavepeople who were successful killers, that is, successful at hunting and killing game, were able to eat and propagate.  The cavepeople who were not good at killing, thus not good at hunting, didn't survive the leaner times where plant based food was scarce.  So that means that the motivation to kill, and the reward for doing so, became an exponential evolutionary cycle.  Inevitably this predatory subroutine became hardcoded into our basal ganglia, and successfully acting upon the deadly instinct excites the ventral tegmental in accordance.  The programming is simple; killing begets food, food begets propagation, propagation begets DNA passes Go collects 200 chromosomes.


Unfortunately that's not all there is to our desire to kill.  There's an uglier side besides mere survival that's actually rooted in tribalism.   In order to survive, our cavepeople ancestors formed tribes.  There's safety and power in numbers after all.  So what are modern countries then, but huge tribes of modern cavepeople?  Assuming the reader lives in a civilized nation with relatively low crime statistics; the very reason you are able to do so is because of past violence and killing.  Don't take my word for it, research the history of any country and you will find malice and death in its origin.  Those who could take, took, and they took by deadly force.  Once taken, they now use deadly force still to keep what they've claimed.  It's true in modern military times, and it was true in sticks and stones times.  People have always killed to keep what they think is theirs.  Violence then, within the human mind, represents strength.  The strength to hold onto territory for the better of the tribe.  And the longer the tribe lasts, the better the chance of status quo survival.  Once again, an avenue of positive reinforcement for violence in the human brain.


Hunting and tribalism are still not the only reasons for our base desire to kill.  The final reason I propose is one of much darker purpose.  It's rooted in a need to establish superiority against perceived threats of inferiority.  To kill a man is to defeat a man?  That's the thought process that seems to motivate many murderers.  Homicides kindled by feelings of vengeance, pure anger, and even fear are nothing new.  When one believes society is beating them down, one might snap and attack society at random (or hopefully just play Manhunt).  Fundamentally many serial killers and spree killers do so as a futile attempt, a means to overcome a deeply rooted inferiority complex.  This homicidal act is not rooted in survivalism, it is rooted rather in mere pride.  Thankfully the vast majority of us are able to overcome these sporadic malevolent urges of wrath and go about our day unaffected.  And the good news is, as video games get better at simulating murder, actual real life murder is declining.  Politicians are starting to notice this, even when they think of the children.


Knowing how deeply rooted violence and killing are in our mortal human essence, it comes as no surprise that murder in video games is so common.  Even something as sweet and innocent as a Kirby game has copious amounts of cotton candy coated death.  Thusly the concept of player induced taking of lives runs the gamut from Mario Goomba squashing to GTA prostitute slaying.  Simply put; it feels good to kill things in video games, because ancient programming in deep parts of our brain tingles our dopamine dispensers happily every single time we do.  Despite humans having been to space and creating the internet, we all still have a bit of cavepeople in us.  Hence the massive sales of Monster Hunter and Minecraft.  Two games that focus on the most basic aspects of hunting and survival.  Not to mention why boutique survival games like Don't Starve and Lost In Blue sell.  Our modern lives have glossed over the ugly parts of being human, but video games will always allow us to virtualize the primal urges.  Ugga kill, Ugga happy.


Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Grown Ups VS Gaming - Part 4 of 4: Evident Evolution

This post is part four of a series beginning with this post.

The above infographic is one I selected at random.  I didn't need to cherry pick because there are many more like it, from various studies and sources.  They all say the same thing.  As people get older, they are continuing to play video games.  The amount of adults who choose to play video games beyond their youth is clearly on the rise.  Adults who believe video games are inherently childish and a waste of time, are in fact a dying breed of dinosaur thinkers.  I'm looking forward to their extinction.  Perhaps the best piece of news lately though, is the amount of women playing video games.

There has been an explosion in recent years concerning the amount of grown females who consider gaming a hobby.  Here are some links to ponder: 1 | 2 | 3 No matter how you slice it, adult women are into gaming now more than ever.  The reason this excites me, is it can lead to more diversification of gaming genres, and gameplay design.  Indeed, many of my favorite video game designers have been female.  Such as Rika Suzuki, Roberta Williams, and Rieko Kodama, to name just a few.  Also I can tell you with full authority that playing co-op campaign games with your significant other is wonderful.  So this is great news for video game loving men seeking video game loving women.  Or video game loving women seeking video game loving women even.  Anyway it's great to see the genders of this medium's demographic evolving beyond the "teenage boy" stereotype.
 
Another positive trend in gaming is the amount of money the industry is making.  There's already been years where the video game industry has surpassed other entertainment mediums.  And is forecast to continue doing so.  This industry is so lucrative, states have begun adding special tax incentives to lure developers.  It stands to reason that not only are more adults playing games, more adults are making their living making them.  I believe in time this will lead to further maturation of the subject matter of game design.  I wouldn't mind the lead protagonist in my next action adventure title being a middle aged man going through a midlife crisis.

Another interesting trend is the amount of senior citizens playing video games.  Maybe this started with the Wii sports phenomenon?  Science says video gaming is good for our elders though, and senior citizen retirement homes are aware of this.  And so is Nintendo.  Well I for one have amassed a backlog that I plan to play well into retirement, that's for sure.

Truly video gaming has never been more robust and widespread than it is today.  Yet I still think we are far from populace saturation insofar as who can play, or what could be played.  Regardless, the point of this series was to show how gaming started out as something that could be seen as childish, but has matured over time into a medium that any respectable adult should enjoy with impunity.  The stereotypes of this hobby are slowly eroding to reveal as diverse a demographic as any other form of entertainment. 

Video games are not for anyone, they are for everyone.  If as a video game playing adult you are ever told you are ever wasting your life enjoying this hobby, remember this Ardent series and don't feel ashamed.  Rather, feel empathetic embarrassment for the ignorance of the person who just said this to you.  Why not invite them to try a game or two?  They might just change their archaic opinion.  Yes fellow gamers, we can erase the last remnants of this stigma, one convert at a time.

Friday, August 29, 2014

Grown Ups VS Gaming - Part 3 of 4: Mature Misconceptions

This post is part three of a series beginning with this post.

"You're an adult and you still play video games? Get a life!"

"Get a life."  That short dismissive phrase is a common one spewed time and again towards adult gamers.  Said phrase is typically muttered towards older gamers by relatives, co-workers, even potential dating partners, when they discover the grown up who still plays video games.  It seems not uncommon for an adult who does not play video games to assume that another adult who does is doing so out of "not having a life".  It's like assuming that all a gamer ever does is play video games, which is entirely not possible, or said gamer would be dead.  In reality the "life" the non-gamer speaks of is the way in which the gamer is spending their free time in regards to entertainment.  But what is the "life" of a typical non-gamer then?  Just what does the average American adult spend their free time on?

The Big Bang Theory and Facebook.  I'm not kidding.  Here are some sources:

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7

Based on the evidence, the average American adult spends about 3 hours of free time each evening watching non-educational television whilst simultaneously browsing Facebook on their smartphone.  That is supposedly the accepted way for an adult to spend their free time.  It's ironic then that some adults would consider myself a 35 year old man as being a childish nerd by playing Ys Origin last night, instead of catching up on the shenanigans of fictional childish nerds on TV instead.

If you talk to adults who don't like video games, they often make consistent arguments as to why they think gaming is useless and childish.  Terms such as "brain rotting", "waste of time", "antisocial", "immature", and "useless" are thrown around often.  Some of those aspects certainly could apply in particular situations, but holistically speaking, they are not inclusively true of the entire medium.  Never mind that any of those terms could arguably be used against the average television show or Facebook post.  All the same, I'll explain my view as to why video games are not necessarily any of those negative things in general.


Are video games brain rotting?  An interactive medium that requires user feedback in order to be enjoyed... cerebrally detrimental?  Even in the simplest of video games, the brain is not going underutilized.  Rather the mind most constantly perceive problems and offer solutions to overcome then.  From something as simple as timing a Mario jump onto a Koopa, to concocting stratagems to defeat a massively challenging boss in a JRPG such as Etrian Odyssey.  After all, video games do not beat themselves, the brain does.  And the brain grows in power as such.  But don't take my word for, read up on the science: 1 | 2 | 3 The truth is, video gaming is actually useful exercise for your grey matter.  Especially if you're into the adventures of this capital chap.

Are video games a waste of time?  I hear this so often about the medium that I plan to do a detailed post about it soon, as the true answers are long.  But I'll keep it simple for now.  If you take time out during your day to devote to entertainment, than any form of entertainment has the potential for being "a waste of time".  Decrying any singular entertainment medium as more a waste of time than another is solely subjective, with no objective logical rational to back the claim.  Truly if you're watching fictional non-educational television for example, in no way is that less a waste of time than playing a fictional non-educational video game.  If you're reading a fantasy book, that's no less a "waste of time" than reading hundreds of pages of text in your average video game RPG.  Let's not forget that ultimately the very point of unwinding via entertainment is to "waste time" and relax in the first place.

Are video games antisocial?  It all depends.  Is someone playing a 3DS on a bus being more antisocial than someone else on that bus who's browsing on an iPhone?  Of course not.  Is a person playing a single player video game alone being any more antisocial than someone reading a book alone?  Have you ever heard of a reader being called antisocial?  And at least another person can watch someone play a single player video game, who wants to watch someone read a book?  I bet you've heard of the Wii.  Want to know why the Wii sold so well?  Because it made local multiplayer gaming easier than ever before.  Hence it had the best selling game of all time, hardly an antisocial experience.  From an online perspective, video games have never been more social with MMO franchises, hence the untold millions Blizzard has made from World Of Warcraft.  And let's not ignore the rising fervor for eSports, an entirely social collective.  The fact is video gaming offers the ability to be the most social medium, due to cooperative gameplay, and competitive gameplay.  And yes it can also be a nice bastion from the ruckus of reality.  But someone choosing to play a video game alone in their bedroom is being no more antisocial than someone listening to an album alone in their bedroom.  The medium of any given type entertainment is irrelevant, rather it's the physical isolation itself that's "antisocial" in nature.  Someone must choose to be antisocial on their own, their hobby doesn't define that for them.

Are video games immature?  That would assume all video games are made for kids.  That's not the case, hence the existence of ESRB ratings. Just as there are films made for kids or adults, there are games made as such.  In that regard video games are not inherently "immature" anymore than films, it's a fallacy to claim as such.  Perhaps a non-gaming grownup would consider the activity of mass slaughter in a title such as God Of War or Grand Theft Auto to be immature in nature.  But to label all of video gaming "immature" by citing games such as those, that is to ignore distinctly polar opposite games in the same medium.  I'm talking about higher brow stuff like Cosmology Of Kyoto or the wonderful works of Kheops Studio, let alone the astonishing output of CiNG. Or is it the very act of interacting with a video game itself that's the immature aspect?  That would mean that if I played chess in real life I was not being immature, yet if I played a chess video game instead I was being immature. Completely illogical.

Are video games useless?  Absolutely not.  I linked earlier to brain studies showing how video games can increase grey matter and improve dexterity.  They are used to train soldiers, teach coding, train pilots, even surgeons.  Sometimes games have unexpected uses, they even help keep thugs off the street, or out of your house.  The benefits of gaming go on, and on, and on.  And I haven't even mentioned how much money the video game industry is worth, and that's billions.  How can you call something that employs thousands of people across the world and feeds their families "useless"?  Not to mention the countless hours of entertainment the industry provides to the entire world on a daily basis.  Video games are about as useless as oxygen.


I hope in writing all this I've helped to shed some light on the hypocrisy of non-gaming adults' misconceptions about the medium.  Or at least provided some ammo the next time you may need to defend your favorite hobby.  The next time someone tells you to "get a life" about playing video games, you can tell them to "get educated" about them instead.  The good news is the entire civilized world's perspective of this medium is shifting over time.  There will come a day when those who think video games are children's play things will be the biased outliers, not in any way the norm.  And that day is coming sooner than they think.  In the next post in this series, I will elaborate upon this illustrious world to come.

This series is continued in this post.

Monday, August 25, 2014

The 5 Golden Rules Of Good Game Design

Today's post is an open letter to all game designers.

Making a good game is not easy.  I know this from experience and from playing plenty of bad games.  While there is no magic formula for making good games, there are simple rules to uphold that can alleviate common mistakes.  It doesn't matter how great your game's graphics are, if it has bad game design it's still a bad game.  By following some simple rules, you can avoid the common mistakes bad game designers employ.  And here are those simple rules:

The 5 Golden Rules Of Good Game Design:

1. Fun First
2. Keep The Controls Simple
3. Never Waste The Player's Time
4. Innovate Always
5. Don't Drag It Out

Yep, that's it.  If you do those five things, your game has a good chance of not being bad.  Now let's take a more detailed look as to why this all matters below.

1. Fun First
If you're making a pure aught video game, you are first and foremost creating a piece of interactive entertainment.  So if your piece of entertainment fails to be entertaining, it has failed its mission in life.  If I'm forcing myself to play your game, you did something wrong.  I should be missing sleep because of how fun your game is, not falling asleep because of how boring it plays.  I should never once think in my head "well maybe it will get better if I just keep going".  If your players ever think that, you screwed up.  Figure out the primary aspect of your game that is fun, and make sure the players are getting to do that fun thing as often as possible.  A game can also not be fun if it's simply too hard.  I appreciate a solid challenge, don't get me wrong.  But anytime you add something extra challenging to your game, ask yourself if it really makes the game any funner.  I promise you, players would rather have breezy fun than be tortured by a game designer's ego.  You better believe players know the difference between legit challenge and pure sadism.  Don't be boring, don't be punitive.  Always put the fun first, everything else comes second.  A game that is not fun is like a shiny car without wheels.  Pretty useless.

 2. Keep The Controls Simple
Take a look at the modern controller, the wireless DualShock 4 for example.  It's got 4 action buttons, 4 triggers, a Share button, an Options button, a PS button, two clickable analog sticks, a d-pad, integral three-axis gyroscope, a capacitive touch pad that also clicks inward as a button, a headphone jack, a USB port, vibration support, a mono speaker, and a light bar with three LEDs that illuminate in different colors that's compatible with both the PlayStation Camera and Project Morpheus.  This thing probably has other features I'm forgetting! WHY do we need such a complicated device to play games with?! It's because most modern game designers are terrible at creating intuitive simple controls.  If more game designers would bother with a simple concept called context sensitivity, we wouldn't need such a complicated controller fit for an octopus.  The same button that lets you shoot can also let you open a door, just make your game realize the situation the player is in.  Learn how to utilize a radial menu, it's perfect for an analog stick.  If your game has complex gameplay, integrate it with NUI methods.  And please don't use every button on the controller just because it's there!  If I come back to your game after a week of not playing it, and I have forgotten how to control it, your controls are unintuitive and too complex.

3. Never Waste The Player's Time
I'm sure most of Ardent's readers have played a modern Zelda game by now.  And I'm sure every one of you have winced after the twentieth time you were told how many rupees a red rupee is worth.  There's no reason why modern Zelda games can't have an option in the menu to disable redundant messages.  The only reason is that the developers don't mind wasting your time.  Other games do this in their own ways.  We all love unskippable movies in our games we're forced to watch every time we fail, right?  NO.  No we don't.  And how many times have you had to replay an entire stage just to fight a boss that kills you in two hits?  Is there any reason why you can't just continue at the boss?  You've already proven you can beat the prior stage, it's not fun to do that over again.  It's just a waste of time.  Too bad the designers don't mind wasting your time.  It's just demeaning, belittling, and aggravating to play a game that treats your precious free time like it's worthless.  So if as a game designer you can't make a game challenging without it being terribly redundant, or needlessly punitive, then guess what?  You are a bad game designer, and your games don't deserve our free time, or our disposable income.  Listen up game designers, don't be like that!  Respect your players' precious time and they will respect your game in tow.  Lastly, progress should be saved at least every fifteen minutes in your game, full stop period.

4. Innovate Always
If you are a game designer, I sure hope you see games as an art form.  And if you do, you should always be looking for ways to further evolve it.  That doesn't mean that every new game you create must reach for the moon with its holistic forward thinking design.  Honestly if you work for a studio beholden to a large publisher, that's probably off the table already.  However, you can follow at least one simple idea.  Make sure your game does at least one new thing that no other game has done before.  I'll give you an example of this.  I played The 3rd Birthday on PSP, it was a third person cover shooter.  A genre that's a bit played out, for sure.  However, this game let you do something I had not seen before.  It let you ghost warp around the battlefield in real time, possessing your allies willy-nilly, adding a whole new frantic dynamic to the experience.  Because of that, what could have been a generic experience became something clever.  So strive for at least one unique twist with every game you design. You're doing the whole industry a favor when you do.

5. Don't Drag It Out
If you're in the gaming business, you've probably heard of How Long To Beat by now.  If not, well, it's a website that tracks how long games take to beat on average.  You might think at first this is something players want to track as a point of pride.  Look at how many hours I sunk into Skyrim or whatever.  The truth more often than not is the opposite.  People want to know how long it's going to take to beat a potential game out of anxiety.  I have seen time and again people on forums deny trying a new game simply because of how long it takes to beat.  So here's the big secret game designers; QUALITY NOT QUANTITY.  I understand you might have a suit breathing down your neck saying your next game needs to be 45 hours long because focus group demographics.  It's just not true.  Most players do not appreciate pointless exposition in game length.  Your players would rather have you invest those extra 20 hours of bloat extension, instead towards polishing 10 hours of awesomeness.  I promise no matter how wonderfully epic you think your game is, it does get boring if it drags on too long.  Protip: Always leave us wanting more, that way we'll actually buy the sequel.

Friday, August 22, 2014

Grown Ups VS Gaming - Part 2 of 4: Troubling Terminology

This post is part two of a series beginning with this post.

What if books were called paper scribbles?  And instead of reading books, you looked at them.  Thus instead of "reading a book", you called the activity looking at paper scribbles.  That's a rather demeaning way to describe the act of mentally digesting literature, no?  And what if films were called flashy pictures?  Does watching flashy pictures sound less distinguished than viewing a film? And what if music albums were called noise gimmicks?  In that case we never played a record, rather we spun noise gimmicks.  Now there's something a proper grown up would not do 'eh?  But luckily in all of those mediums, there exists classier terminology widely accepted culturally.  Too bad video games got a bad rap then.


Think about the name "video game" objectively.  Is that not a rather rote term for something as amazing as what it actually is?  The marriage of technology, multiple art forms, artificial reality, and actual interactivity... a brilliant cluster of potential.  Yet we commonly call this phenomenon simply a "video game".  Apparently a description that an unknown reporter coined for the magazine Vending Times during a Chicago tradeshow in 1971 (source).  Granted calling an unusual bit of technology a name based on its pure fundamentals was understandable... at that time. Unfortunately 43 years later this saddled name does not adequately encompass the scope of the medium today.  And yet we are still stuck with it culturally.  The medium therefore suffers the consequence of ignorance based on its illicit implication.  It's not the "video" part of course.  That just implies a picture in motion, fair enough.  It's the "game" part.


"Games are for children."  This is not an uncommon thought for a grown up to have.  Okay, sure, "ring around the rosy", "duck duck goose", "hide and go seek", "tag your it"... these are games that children commonly play.  As an adult, I don't find those activities very alluring.  It sounds about as fun as running around in the dirt kicking a ball.  Oh, sorry, that's soccer.  A game grown men are culturally allowed to play and are often paid millions of dollars to do so.  Honestly I don't have any problems with soccer.  But I do have a problem with any adult who has issues with other adults playing soccer video games.  Just because they're video games.  Yes it's hypocritical.  But in some folks' minds soccer is not merely a game see, because society leaves off the "game" part of its namesake conveniently.


So what's a better name for "video games"?  A common phrase I've seen in critic circles is interactive entertainment.  I agree that's a better description than "video game".  However, I don't particularly adhere to it either.  Primarily because it attributes the medium as being purely entertainment.  I don't deny a huge swath of the medium is geared towards that aspect, but it's hardly solely that.  Video games have long been used as training tools by the military and commercial pilots.  In that sense video games cease being entertainment, and are called simulators instead.  But we can't call the next Mario title a simulator.  Unless you're training to squash turtles and slide down questionable conduits.

What then are some better names for the term "video game"?  If you have some, leave me a comment below.  Personally, I'm fond of the descriptor "digital".  I can't offhand think of any electronic video game that isn't digital.  Continuing with that theme, digitals consist of programming code.  When this code executes, that's called "running the program".  So howabout instead of saying, "I'm going to play video games," instead you said, "I'm going to run digitals."  I think that sounds pretty badass and cyberpunky myself.


Whether or not you like my suggestion, I do hope you agree that "video games" as a descriptor of the medium is just outmoded.  It's a term that's overly simplistic and demeaning, if not outright archaic and slanderous.  Said nomenclature perpetuates the myth that video games are nothing but games amongst the culturally biased.  I strongly believe as a society we need to replace this term with one of greater breadth and relevance.  This could go a long way towards alleviating some of the prejudice and misconceptions non-gamers have towards gaming itself.  On the next Ardent post in this series, I'll talk about some of those misconceptions, explaining why they're both illogical and hypocritical.

This series is continued in this post.

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Grown Ups VS Gaming - Part 1 of 4: Haunted History

Quiz Time

As an adult, how do you consider video games?

(A) - An excellent source of entertainment with artistic merit.
(B) - An excellent source of entertainment.
(C) - A waste of time.
(D) - Childish playthings that grown people should have nothing to do with.
(E) - All of the above.

If you answered A, congratulations, we're on the same page.  If you answered B, then you may find a future Ardent post about "games as art" interesting.  If you answered C, then you may find a future Ardent post about "what's the point of gaming" interesting.  If you answered D, then today's article (and its follow ups) are for you.  If you answered E, you're just being deliberately obstinate but I can admire that.
Honestly though, I have to assume people currently reading this blog are at least somewhat into video games, and are likely grown up.  But that doesn't mean they don't have some level of shame about it.  Even more likely, Ardent's readers know other adults who would think less of them if said adults knew about their gaming hobby. So why is it in this day and age video games don't have cultural immunity the likes of which books, movies, music, and other mediums enjoy?  I propose it's a matter of history, obsolete terminology, and perpetuated misconceptions.  The good news is, all of these problems will erode over time.  The bad news is, probably not before our children's grandchildren grow up.  Anyway, let's address the first issue that causes bias against gaming; history.
Now I'm not about to go into massive detail about the history of gaming.  (If you're interested in that, I'm sure you can find a dozen books about the subject on Amazon.)  I will go over some generalizations however.  For example, most folks know video games started off with very primitive things like Pong.   A game as simple as Pong or even Space Invaders only had a few key merits at their time.  One was technological, the other was mere spectacle, the last was simple fun.  The technological aspect attracted folks interested in how such things worked.  The spectacle aspect attracted even your grandmother, for a moment, and then she walked away.  The simple fun?  It attracted kids.  Anyone who's ever experienced a smiling five year old watch a Disney DVD for the 12th time knows young kids don't mind rote repetition.  That was what video gaming was like at first.  Technology, spectacle, and simple fun.  And these things set many precedents which affect the way the world sees video gaming even today.  But first let's see how they affected things then.

 
The technology attracted tech loving gurus who in turn took this new medium and got deep with it pretty quickly.  They created and enjoyed stuff like Beneath Apple Manor, Colossal Cave Adventure, and Akalabeth: World Of Doom.  The problem was that although these new games were complicated enough for adults to enjoy, they weren't easy to come across.  You would not find complex CRPGs in your local arcade.  So although there were sophisticated video games in the very beginning of this medium, they were obscure and ran on expensive equipment.  These were geek games for geeks by geeks.  And as amazing as these elder geek games were, being almost clandestine they did nothing to help the public image of gaming.  Your grandma still doesn't know Dungeon existed.

Granny does know what Pac-Man was though.  And that's because it was a huge part of the age of spectacle and simple fun, the golden age of the arcade.  There was a time where arcade cabinets could be found anywhere.  The pizza parlor, the gas station, roller rinks, movie theaters... I wouldn't doubt they were in the rest rooms of Las Vegas casinos at one time.  What this meant was average Joe had massive exposure to the spectacle of video games... but only in the sense of what they had to offer as simple fun.  A successful arcade game had to be instantly understandable to the player, in order to suck a few quarters down before they got bored and walked away.  Or in the kid's case, until the quarters ran out.

Perhaps it was the incessant nagging of kids for quarters from their parents to play these simple arcade games, that began to set a negative precedent.  This situation was made exponential by vendors pushing video game devices as being toys meant for children.  If you go back and look at ads in the early days of gaming, you'll notice the ads often push the "your kid loves this stuff" aspect hard.  Here are some examples: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5  And if the ad didn't push that aspect, it fell back to the spectacle stance.  Video games were falling from grace as a new medium into simply a lucrative fad increasingly targeting kids and their parents' money.  This toxic mixture of spectacle and simple fun didn't work out so well for the games industry back then, but that's a different story.

What matters today is that the precedent set in parents' heads during that time continues to trickle into our culture today.  "Video games are flashy spectacles that provide simple fun for children."  Many grown folks thought that then, for the same reason they think it now.  Ignorance of the medium and its complexity.  A lack of perspective about the potential of video games.  Well when someone dislikes something out of ignorance, that only perpetuates bias.  Thus a cultural bias in large enough quantity certainly can instill shame in those who defy it.  This bias began decades ago as a side effect, and manages to perpetuate to a noticeable degree even today.


All the same, a bad history is only the first problem video games have as a medium.  A following Ardent post in this series will address the second issue... the terminology itself.  Indeed, video games harbor a default juvenile slant simply due to being called video games.  The rabbit hole goes deeper than that, but that's where we'll start to dig next.

This series is continued in this post.